In my spare time I often aimlessly scroll around eBay looking for affordable basketball cards that belong in my collection for one reason or another. Just the other day, I came across a bizarre Ray Allen rookie card with a robot reaching around Ray’s upper thigh and it got me thinking about other wacky basketball cards I’ve encountered over the years.
There are a number of famous sports cards that collectors gravitate to just because they are weird, funny, or interesting. Two of the most famous baseball cards in this category are the very famous “F*ck Face” Bill Ripken Fleer card and the “Rally Squirrel” Skip Schumaker Topps card.
With this post, I’m working to catalog as many of the strangest or funniest basketball cards I’ve come across as well as highlighting their ungraded and top graded PSA values. If you know of other odd, funny, or outright bizarre basketball cards please comment and I’ll be sure to add them to this list.
1998-99 Fleer Ultra Basketball #24: David Wesley
There are some basketball sets that are known for being a bit silly (1996-97 Upper Deck is one… more on this set later), but the 1998-99 Fleer Ultra set featured normal cards, more or less. One very notable exception is card #24 featuring Charlotte Hornets point guard David Wesley.
For whatever reason, the good folks over at Fleer wanted to capture Wesley in a ball pit being read to by the Hornets mascot. It doesn’t get much weirder than this.
In case this card interests you, its very easy to find on eBay for around $1. There is also a Gold Medallion copy (#24G) that is likely more rare but is equally affordable on eBay.
The 1973-74 Topps basketball set features some incredible players, including Julius Erving, John Havlicek, Phil Jackson, Oscar Robertson, Pete Maravich, Jerry West, Kareem Abdul-Jabar, and many other HOFers from the 1970s. It also has some very odd cards that were staged in strange locations.
One of the strangest staged images from the set is card #99 featuring Chicago Bulls power forward Garfield Heard. As you can see below, the Heard photo looks like it was shot in a locker room of sorts. Heard wasn’t the only player in the 1973-74 Topps set to look a bit out of place. In fact, the cards featuring, Howard Porter, Jerry Sloan, Don Nelson, Bob McAdoo, and other all look like they were shot in a hallway.
The Garfield Heard card sells for about $1 on eBay, but there are some other players mentioned earlier that sell for top dollar at high grades. The highest selling card from this set featuring a ton of legends and super stars is card #135 featuring Bob McAdoo.
This card, despite being staged in a hallway, is McAdoo’s rookie card and the top graded PSA 10 cards sell for as much as $7K. These cards are very difficult to find in GEM mint condition and the population for PSA 10 McAdoo rookies is limited to just 4 cards! PSA 9s are also quite scarce with a population of just 67 and they have been know to sell for over $1,500.
1996-97 Upper Deck
The 1996-97 basketball season is one of the hottest years for basketball card collectors due in large part to an incredible rookie class featuring players like Allen Iverson, Ray Allen, and Kobe Bryant. While Topps debuted the wildly popular Topps Chrome set in 1996-97, Upper Deck went in a wacky direction with bizarre player photos, featuring players like Steve Nash, Wesley Person, and Martin Muursepp photographed away from the hardwood.
The Steve Nash rookie card (#280) is hands down my favorite card in this set, featuring Nash on skates winding up with a hockey stick and smiling for the camera.
The top graded GEM Mint PSA 10 Nash on skates rookie card is still quite affordable, with the last two PSA 10 sales selling for $100 or less. The PSA 9 was selling in the $30-$50 range, but the most recent sale on March 14, 2021 sold for $111, perhaps that is an outlier. These Nash rookies are very common on eBay, and you should be able to find one for $5 or less.
Other very strange cards from this set include Miami Heat forward Martin Muursepp (#245), Phoenix Suns shooting guard Wesley Person (#281), and Milwaukee Bucks point guard Elliot Perry (#250). Of those three cards, the hardest one to find for sale on eBay was the Muursepp card. The lowest price I was able to find for the Muursepp card was a Buy It Now price of $9.
1991-92 Upper Deck #37: Dee Brown
The 1991-92 Upper Deck set was more or less all normal looking cards, and as far as crazy basketball cards go this one is probably the least crazy on the list. However, the Dee Brown card has always stuck out to me as an interesting card since its the only one I’ve ever seen featuring a player sitting on the rim.
Not only is Brown sitting on the rim, but he’s also holding his 1991 Gatorade Slam Dunk Champion trophy. Brown defeated Shawn Kemp with his “no look” dunk, where he famously covered his eyes with his right forearm and finished with his left hand.
For sneaker collectors out there, this card also clearly features the super popular 1991 Reebok Pump Omni Lite shoe. If you grew up in the 90s, the Reebok pump shoes were a must have for any aspiring basketball player.
This card is a $1 card on eBay and there is very little PSA data available on their website, since it looks like only a few cards have been graded. I did find on SCG 9.5 graded copy of this card selling on eBay for $35, but that was the only graded copy available.
1996-97 Metal Universe Cyber Metal Inserts
Steve Nash wasn’t the only player from the 1996-97 rookie class to come away with an interesting looking rookie card. In fact, the 1996-97 Fleer Metal set (one of my personal favorites) had unique insert called Cyber Metal, some of which included the design of a handsy golden robot that led to some weird looking cards. From a distance, none of the robot Cyber Metal cards look too strange, but when you get a closer look at the robot’s hand placement things look a little inappropriate.
The Ray Allen Cyber Metal rookie card (#2) was the card I was referring to up at the top of this post. The chosen card design, with the robot reaching around and touching or pinching Allen’s upper thigh, is a very poor and bizarre design choice.
There are probably hundreds of different ways to incorporate a robot into this design, but Fleer just happened to find one of the worst ways of doing so. To state the obvious, the handsy robot is a bit too close to Ray Allen’s “no no square” if you’re picking up what I’m putting down.
(Please note, these cards are very difficult to photograph and look much better in person. The below image of Ray Allen was the best images I was able to find.)
On eBay, the Cyber Metal Ray Allen rookie card sells in a very wide range. In April, 2021 I saw this card selling for as low as $8 and as high as $99. There isn’t a ton of data on PSA’s website, but the most recent PSA 9 sale, in March 2021, sold for $67. There were no GEM Mint PSA 10 sales listed on the website.
What really gives the robot in the background an 11 out of 10 creep factor is the fact that it doesn’t just lay it’s hands on Allen’s thigh, but it looks like it is trying to pull the exact same move with Kobe Bryant. The Kobe Cyber Metal rookie is the 5th card in the set and its an awesome shot of Kobe, but Fleer still has the robot in the background grabbing for Kobe’s upper thigh. I’m just not sure what the design team was thinking…
The ungraded copies of the Kobe Cyber Metal rookie are plentiful on eBay, but they will set you back a few hundred dollars. The lowest priced Buy It Now card available on eBay was selling for $200, while the highest priced Buy It Now card was asking $900. There were also a few ungraded auctions.
There is a good amount of PSA data listed on their website, and if you own a copy of this card that looks to be in perfect condition is could easily be worth your wile to have it graded. The total population of GEM Mint PSA 10 Kobe Cyber Metal cards is 79, and the most recent sale of a PSA 10 went for just under $6K in early March, 2021. The most recent sales for PSA 9s have been selling in a range of $650-$900. But if we go back to February of 2020, these cards were selling for only $40-$50!
Not all 20 of the Cyber Metal cards feature the robot. While I was researching, the only other instances of the robot I was able to find were the 9th card in the set featuring Stephon Marbury, the 16th card featuring Gary Payton, and the 20th card featuring Chris Webber. The Webber Cyber Metal card actually shows the robot reaching for the basketball and appears to be the only time the robot isn’t reaching for or touching a players upper thigh.
1990-91 NBA Hoops
Perhaps the most macabre basketball card of all time is the 1990-91 NBA Hoops card featuring Mark Jackson (#205). On the surface, there is nothing notably funny or interesting going on with Jackson himself, but in the background sitting courtside are Lyle and Erik Menendez.
The Menendez brothers were an infamous pair who murdered their parents in the den of the family’s Beverly Hills home in the summer of 1989. The Menendez brothers murder story drew national attention in 1993 when Court TV broadcast the trial. The brothers were convicted in 1996 and sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.
As a result of the 1990-91 NBA Hoops set hitting the printers in the midst of the “junk card era”, there are tons of copies of this card available on eBay. If you’re looking to add an ungraded card to your collection, you should be able to find one for around $5.
This is one of the most popular graded cards from this set, with over 500 graded copies. GEM Mint PSA 10 copies are quite rare however, with a population of only 31. There have been 8 PSA 10 sales thus far in 2021, with the lowest selling for $290 and the highest selling on March 10th for $590.
The PSA 9s are much more common, but there isn’t a huge drop off as you might expect going down from a PSA 10 to a PSA 9. The three most recent sales of PSA 9s have sold for $211, $203, and $143. One interesting note is that last year in March and April the PSA 9 Mark Jackson cards were selling in the $20-$40 range.
The second most interesting card from this set is card #223 featuring Orlando Magic guard Sam Vincent. This card is notable not because of anyone in the background, but rather the photo was taken during a game where Michael Jordan’s jersey was stolen, so its the only card showing Jordan wearing the #12 jersey.
This card is also plentiful on eBay, and like the ungraded Jackson card, this one should be an easy pickup for around $5. There are only about 120 PSA graded copies of this card, and of those 25 received a GEM Mint PSA 10 grade.
The top graded copies of this card have very recently popped in value. Recent sales for the Vincent PSA 10 are around $500, with the three most recent sales in February, 2021 selling for $550, $510, and $480. However, as early as November 2021 this card was only selling for $50, so perhaps hobbyists have re-discovered this card.
The PSA 9s are very affordable and have been selling in the $20-$40 range. With the new price hikes from PSA, if you can find a PSA 9 Sam Vincent card for under $20 I would hop on that. I expect this card will continue to resonate and appreciate in value, since it is the only know card featuring Jordan in the #12 jersey.
If you know of any other noteworthy or bizarre cards that I missed, please message me or comment and I’ll be sure to update and to this list.